Sara Flower
Sara Elizabeth Flower (21 October 1820 – 20 August 1865)[1] was a British-born contralto[2] singer who became Australia's first opera star. She began a musical career in London during the 1840s before emigrating to Australia in late 1849. In 1852, she appeared in Sydney in the first production in Australia of Bellini's opera Norma.[3]

Life
Flower was born in the English market town of Grays, Essex, situated on the River Thames at the edge of the Tilbury marshes. In 1821, Grays had a population of 742, supporting six public houses.[4] The Rising Sun public house was owned by Flower's maternal grandfather, Daniel Granger. The nearby Belmont Castle was a strong influence on regional music.[5]
Family
Sara's father was William Lewis Flower (c.1800-1847), who was recorded in the Essex Directory in 1823 as being a draper, grocer, and agent for Phoenix Fire & Life. In order to claim the status of gentleman, he later stated that he had 'no occupation' when his daughter was admitted to the Royal Academy of Music in 1841.[6]
Sara's uncle, Robert Flower (c.1779-1832), was a foreman of the local brickworks in 1824. As he was described as a yeoman in local parish records from 1817, he likely came from an earlier lineage of tenant farmers or small proprietors. This drop in social status likely came from changes brought about by the enclosure movement after the Napoleonic Wars.[7]
Her mother, Ruth Flower, was the daughter of local Grays publican Daniel Granger. Little is known about her, but she may have been the prototype for the mother of a fictional opera singer whose sad fate she prophetically foretells in Alice Diehl's first published novel, Garden of Eden.[8]
Sara's elder sister Elizabeth also became a public singer as a soprano. Both sisters developed a considerable concert career in the 1840s, performing often as a duo regionally and in London. They sang to much acclaim, and Sara especially was noted for her startling[9] voice. In 1847, Elizabeth married a prominent lawyer called Timms Augustine Sargood and withdrew from public life. At their home in London's Bloomsbury district (Gordon Square), she and her husband were the hosts of a musical circle in the 1860s, however. Guests included concert pianist Diehl, who Elizabeth recounted in two autobiographical works.
Sara and Elizabeth were frequently confused with Sarah Fuller Flower Adams and Eliza Flower, who were daughters of political writer Benjamin Flower and respectively acclaimed as a poet and composer in their own right. This confusion persisted throughout Sara's life and after her death.[10] No connection between the two families has been established, but there were notable similarities in economic, social, and regional backgrounds.
Education and training
From late October 1841, Flower was trained at the Royal Academy of Music (R.A.M) under Domenico Crivelli (1794–1857). Domenico was educated by his father, singer Gaetano Crivelli (1774–1836),[11] in techniques of Italian castrati such as the exploitation of falsetto. This may account for Flower's protean ability to cross the entire range of the operatic singing voice. In Bellini's Norma, her range spread from the dramatic soprano of Norma to the mezzo of Analgias, in addition to the tenor role of Pollioni.
Early career
Flower first came to public notice within the Psalmody Movement[12] of the 1830s and 40s in London. The movement was associated with such names as Sarah Ann Glover, John Hullah and John Curwen. It had strong Independent, or Congregationalist non-conformist religious leanings, and a powerful utilitarian sociology. On 4 November 1839, the Musical World noted that Sara and her sister had both appeared at a lecture given at the Hoxton National School Room in inner North London by Charles Henry Purday (1799–1885), known for his theories on 'The Proper Object of Music'.[13]
Flower was believed to be connected with John Hullah's classes in London's Exeter Hall.[14] Flower was also believed to be associated with "Music for the Million", the singing school of Joseph Mainzer (1801–1851),[15] which had been modeled on the monitorial method of Guillaume Louis Bocquillon Wilhem [1781–1842] and his 'Orphéon' choral fests[16] for teaching often illiterate working people to sight-sing from notation sheets as a non-conformist socio-religious project to revitalize music education in the Anglican Church.[17]
Contrary to conjecture around deeper links to non-conformism and/or the Psalmody Movement, a post-1847 Flower family memorial plaque on the walls of the Grays parish church of St Peter and St Paul does not suggest any powerful non-conformist link, nor does her R.A.M. career under the dictatorial rule of its President, John Fane, Lord Burghersh (1784–1859).[18]
British professional career
Around 4 November 1839 she assisted C. H. Purday in presenting a lecture titled "The Proper Object of Music" at the Hoxton National School Room, London. On 29 October 1841 she was admitted to the Royal Academy of Music, London as a student of singing.
Her operatic debut was on 7 January 1843 at the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane, as the peasant Pippo, in Macready's concert version of Rossini's La gazza ladra, starring Sabilla Novello as Annette. She would reprise that role with full orchestra at the Princess's Theatre with Emma Albertazzi as Annette from 17 July the same year, having in that theatre from 17 April 1843 appeared in Rossini's Tancredi in the name role. She played Adina in Donizetti's L'elisir d'amore, from 11 October 1843 with Paul Bedford as Dulcamara, and Rebecca Isaacs as Floretta. She made a few appearances on the concert stage, then left for Italy to further her studies.
On her return to London she made a series of appearances at the Princess's Theatre: as Bertha Edward Loder's Night Dancers, with Emma Albertazzi as Giselle from 28 October 1846, and Ernestine in George Rodwell's Seven Maids of Munich from 19 December 1846. Donizetti's Anna Bolena as Smeaton followed on 12 January 1847, starring Louisa Bassano in the name part, Mendelssohn's Midsummer Night's Dream as Oberon from 23 April 1847, and as Donna Olympia in Loder's The Young Guard, starring Anna Thillon from 20 January 1848.
Flower took part in several concerts at the Surrey Zoological Gardens, Louis-Antoine Jullien's Concerts Monstre on 24 July 1848 and 28 September 1848.
Around this time she was a member of the corps musicale attending the ninth reunion of the General Theatrical Fund held at the London Tavern, Bishopsgate Street, chaired by Sir Edward Bulwer-Lytton and supported by Charles Dickens.[19]
She emigrated to Australia on the migrant ship Clifton, which left London on 14 November 1849.
Life in Australia

Clifton, of 867 tons, E. W. Beasley, commander, from London the largest of three emigrant ships chartered by John Dunmore Lang, arrived in Port Phillip with some 200 emigrants, mostly from Evangelical Churches. Lang was one of the 20-odd named cabin passengers, and it must be assumed Flower travelled in steerage.[20]
Her first Australian performance was in Melbourne, at the Mechanics' Institute on 28 February 1850, for Reed. This was advertised as her only Melbourne appearance, as she was to continue to Sydney aboard Clifton, but was persuaded to appear again for Reed at the Queen's Theatre on 26 March[21] and proceed to Sydney aboard Asia. She was to join her brother,[22] believed to be George Flower (died 16 July 1890), manager of the Commercial Bank in Muswellbrook c. 1867–1890.[23] but whose earlier occupation has not been found. She arrived on 15 April 1850 and made her first Sydney appearance at the Victoria Theatre on 3 May 1850 for S. and H. Marsh.[24]
Sara Flower married Samuel Howard Taylor of Sydney on 20 December 1851. He turned to the stage in 1855 as Sam Howard, low comedian.[25]
She was the first Norma in Australia. Two characters in which she made a great impression were Azucena in Il trovatore and Maffio Orsini in Lucrezia Borgia.[26]
Later Years
She suffered from rheumatism, and in her last years was unable even to take students. She died, destitute but proud, at her residence, 137 Victoria Street, Woolloomooloo on 20 August 1865[27] and her body was interred at the old Devonshire Street Cemetery on the following day; a single coach carried her mourners. Her remains were later transferred to the new cemetery at La Perouse, where a monument was placed on her grave be a group of enthusiasts.[28]
Voice
Various British and Australian newspaper reports of the period describe Flower's voice and vocal affect with terms such as volume; melody; compass; resonance; sonorousness; simplicity; cultivation; powerful; exquisite; flexible; rich; full; distinct; nervous; rare; delicious; sweet; mellow; liquid; welling; gushing; wonderful; expressive; clear; enchanting; perfect; delightful; wonderful; extraordinary; thrilling; electrifying; melancholy; noble; pure; magnificent; splendid; glorious; astonishing; commanding; great; masterly; force of expression; sensation; harmony; charm; liveliness; ease; heart-pathos; depth of feeling; emotional power; tenderness; a host in itself; divine; beyond praise; heaven; a treasure; the great contralto.
On 7 January 1843, Sara Flower made her anonymous London debut in a opera at Drury Lane as an all-but non-singing Felix (Pippo) to Sabilla Novello's Annette (the youngest daughter of music publisher Vincent Novello) in a hybrid Macready production of Rossini's opera La gazza ladra (The Thieving Magpie). The opera was characterized as 'little more than a melodrama with a few airs interspersed'.[29]
A review on Sara's recitative introduction in a duet role with Annette in 'Ebben per mia' reported her positive reception:
'her notes were so exceedingly full and rich, her articulation so admirable, rare qualities in an English singer of recitative, that the audience were literally taken by surprise, and uttered loud and continuous applause, which was frequently reiterated as the very superior quality of her voice was exhibited in the course of the duet'.[9]
The reviewer described her voice then as 'a mezzo-soprano of singular volume, with some excellent contralto notes, which she touches with firmness'. The unusual review went beyond the norm of describing the voice to also cover the reaction of an audience which cried out spontaneously over a few bars of recitative.[30]
Contemporary London comment associated Flower's voice with that of Marietta Brambilla (1807–1875) as possessing a 'contralto voice of [...] delicious voluptuous quality'.[31] Six years later in Australia, Flower's voice was described as being "like one of those boy-voices that one meets with once in one's life and remembers for ever after, so clear, so full, and nervous, and of such volume and compass".[32]
Notes and references
- Essex County Record Office (Chelmsford), Baptismal Records, Grays.
- Fisher, Rod (May 2000). "Silvester Diggles: Brisbane's pioneer musician, scientist, artist and New Churchman". Journal of the Royal Historical Society of Queensland.
- A. V. Beedell, Terminal Silence: Sara Flower and the Diva Enigma. Explorations of Voice and the Maternal in Operatic Experience in Colonial Australian History ca. 1850–1865 in 2 vols., Griffith University, Brisbane, Australia, 2000, 2 vols
- New British Traveller (1784), in Laurie Leeham, 'From Stocks to Docks' Essex Countryside August 1967 pp.53+; William White 1848, History, Gazeteer, & Directory of the County of; Essex; Essex Directory [1823], p. 294.
- Alice Diehl 1897, Musical Memories, London; [1897]; The True Story of My Life. An Autobiography [1905], London.
- Royal Academy of Music, Register. She had been admitted, 21 October 1841 upon the recommendation of the Academy's founder, John Fane Lord Burghersh, later 11th earl of Westmoreland, soldier, diplomat and amateur opera composer.
- Essex County Record Office. Grays Parish, baptism records for his many children, almost all of whom pre-deceased him. For conditions for the remnants of the yeomanry - the English tenant farmers of the 1820s and 30s - see William Cobbett for a contemporary account in his Rural Rides of 1830.
- The concert pianist Alice Diehl was the author of at least 41 novels. She also wrote two works of autobiography: Musical Memories, London, [1897], and The True Story of My Life. An Autobiography [1905], London. She grew up in the same area, in nearby Averley, granddaughter of the local Doctor, Charles Lewis Vidal (1782-1862), and her autobiographical works show that she and her family were social associates of the Flowers of Grays, either through a local music making a circle at Belmont Castle where Diehl's mother was a favourite, or perhaps kinship. The 'Alice Diehl' entry in 'Thurrock Heritage - Factfiles' particularly in relation to the identification of 1882 as the publication date of Diehl's first novel, considered by this source to have been Garden of Eden provides some support for the proposition. [www.thurrock.gov.uk/heritage] The British Library's copy is dated 1907, possibly the Library's accession date.
- The Times 'Drury Lane Theatre', 9 January 1843, p.4f.
- The Australian Monthly Magazine vol. I, no.1, September 1865 in a short obituary commented, 'We believe she was sister to Eliza Flower, composer of that beautiful English sacred glee — 'Now pray we for our country', and we trust that those who can afford it will see to it that posterity shall not look in vain for the resting place of one who certainly was among the pioneers of opera in Australia.'; in other words that she was the poet Sarah Fuller Flower Adams, who had written the words for the enduring hymn 'Nearer my God to Thee', set to music by her sister Eliza Flower.
- See Grove 1961, vol. 2, p. 536 for these life dates
- Part of a wider musical/social phenomenon broadly constructed around the philosophical idealism of Johann Heinrich Pestalozzi modified, however by the utilitarianism of Jeremy Bentham. See Rachel Cowgill and Peter Holman Music in the British Provinces 1690-1914 (Ashgate, 2007; Bernarr Rainbow 1970, The Choral Revival in the Anglican Church (1839–1872). (London, Barrie & Jenkins)
- The title of the lecture is an echo of the title of the 1824 Quarterly Musical Magazine [QMMR] article on a work of 1807 by Guillaume André Villoteau, following Pestalozzi, extolling music as a pleasure unique in its moral effect; able 'to elevate and ennoble the soul by purifying and strengthening the mind'. (QMMRvol.vi, pp.39-40). Purday himself was a well-known singer, lecturer, editor and composer of popular songs and hymns, also conductor of psalmody to the Scottish Church in Crown Street, Covent Garden, and composer of the popular hymn, 'Lead Kindly Light'. Grove 1961, vol. 6, p. 1022
- Sydney Morning Herald 'Contributions from Home', No. 18', 18 February 1851, p.4f
- Musical Times 1 October 1844, p. 39.
- Wilhem was Musical director-general of music in the municipal schools of Paris. Based upon a plan of 'Mutual Instruction', he developed a huge music education organization (Orphéon) throughout France. (See Grove 1961, vol. 9, pp.298-99)
- Bernarr Rainbow 1970, The Choral Revival in the Anglican Church (1839-1872). (London, Barrie & Jenkins)
- Later 11th earl of Westmorland; soldier, diplomat and amateur opera composer, generally considered to have been the found of the R.A.M. in 1839. His works, all within the genre of Italian opera, were often rehearsed by R.A.M. students. Flower probably had the perfect alto voice for his project, and probably for her teaching master, Domenico Crivelli.
- "General Theatrical Fund". The Sydney Daily Advertiser. No. 82. New South Wales, Australia. 4 September 1848. p. 2. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- "Shipping Intelligence". The Melbourne Daily News. Vol. XIII, no. 3087. Victoria, Australia. 13 February 1850. p. 2. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- "Advertising". The Melbourne Daily News. Vol. XIII, no. 3121. Victoria, Australia. 25 March 1850. p. 2. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- "Local Intelligence". The Melbourne Daily News. Vol. XIII, no. 3099. Victoria, Australia. 27 February 1850. p. 2. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- "Muswellbrook". The Maitland Mercury and Hunter River General Advertiser. Vol. XLVII, no. 6589. New South Wales, Australia. 17 July 1890. p. 5. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- "Death of Madame Sara Flower". The Sydney Morning Herald. Vol. LII, no. 8529. New South Wales, Australia. 21 September 1865. p. 5. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- "Death of Mr Sam Howard, Comedian". The Lorgnette. Vol. XLIII. Victoria, Australia. 11 October 1886. p. 2. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- "Madame Sara Flower". The Sydney Mail and New South Wales Advertiser. Vol. LXXIII, no. 2176. New South Wales, Australia. 22 March 1902. p. 741. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- "The Metropolitan Stage". Bell's Life In Victoria and Sporting Chronicle. Vol. 10, no. 383. Victoria, Australia. 26 August 1865. p. 2. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- "Madame Sara Flower". The Australian Star. No. 4422. New South Wales, Australia. 19 April 1902. p. 3. Retrieved 17 September 2022 – via National Library of Australia.
- Musical World 12 January 1843, p. 22
- Michel Poizat 1992, The Angel's Cry. Beyond the Pleasure Principle in Opera
- Musical World 22 February 1844
- Sydney Morning Herald (SMH), 'Parramatta Concert', 8 July 1850, p. 3a.
- Beedell, A.V. 2000, 'Terminal Silence: Sara Flower and the Diva Enigma: Explorations of Voice and the Maternal in Operatic Experience in Colonial Australian History ca. 1850-1865' in 2 volumes. PhD Faculty of Arts, Griffith University, Queensland.
- Diehl, Alice [1897] Musical Memories, (London)
- Diehl, Alice [1905] The True Story of My Life. An Autobiography, (London)
- Grove's Dictionary of Music and Musicians 1961, 5th ed. edited by Eric Blom (London, Macmillan)
- Gyger, Alison, "Flower, Sara Elizabeth", Australian Dictionary of Biography, Online Edition (accessed 18 January 2010)
- Musical World (London 1836-91)
- Poizat, Michel 1992, The Angel's Cry. Beyond the Pleasure Principle in Opera, trans. Arthur Denner (Ithaca and London)
- Rainbow, Bernarr 1970, The Choral Revival in the Anglican Church (1839–1872). (London, Barrie & Jenkins)
- Stendhal (Henri Beyle) 1956 [1824] Life of Rossini trans. Richard N. Coe, London
- Times, The (London)
External references
- 'Cowgill, Rachel and Peter Holman 2007, Music in the British Provinces 1690-1914 (Ashgate)'
- 'Thurrock Heritage - Factfiles [Alice Diehl]' www.thurrock.gov.uk/heritage
- https://monumentaustralia.org.au/themes/people/arts/display/21784-sara-flower